Bolton Analysis for Clear Aligner Planning
A setup can look perfect from the front and still finish with a stubborn overjet, small spaces that keep reopening, or canines that never reach Class I. Often the reason is simple: the upper and lower teeth are not in proportion. No amount of staging fixes a mismatch in tooth size, but spotting it before you approve the plan lets you decide in advance how to deal with it.
The Bolton analysis is the standard way to check this. This article explains what it measures, how to use it with digital records, how much to trust the numbers your software gives you, and the practical options when a discrepancy is found.
What the Bolton analysis measures
The analysis compares the combined mesiodistal widths of the lower teeth with those of the upper teeth and expresses the result as a percentage.
- Anterior ratio: the six lower anterior teeth (canine to canine) divided by the six upper anterior teeth, multiplied by 100.
- Overall ratio: the twelve lower teeth from first molar to first molar divided by the twelve upper teeth, multiplied by 100.
Bolton's reference values were 77.2% for the anterior ratio and 91.3% for the overall ratio (as reported by Vorloeper et al., 2024). A ratio above the reference suggests the lower teeth are relatively large (or the upper teeth small); a ratio below it suggests the opposite. Converting the difference into millimetres tells you where the excess lies and how much tooth material is involved, which is far more useful for planning than the percentage alone.
Why it matters more with aligners
With fixed appliances, a clinician can see a small discrepancy appear late in treatment and adjust with wire bends, stripping or elastics. With aligners, the finish is largely decided when you approve the setup. If the software moves teeth into a tidy final position without accounting for a size mismatch, the plan on screen may only be achievable by quietly adding stripping, leaving spaces or changing incisor angulation.
Checking the Bolton ratios before approval lets you see which of these the setup has chosen, and whether that choice suits the patient. Our guide on reviewing a 3D aligner setup explains where this fits in the wider review.
Reference values are not universal
Studies in other groups of patients suggest that Bolton's figures should not be applied rigidly to everyone.
A large study measured digital models of 1,000 consecutive patients from three centres using partially automated software. Both the anterior and the overall ratios were significantly higher than Bolton's values. Male patients tended to have larger ratios, mainly in the overall measure, and patients with Class II division 1 or 2 malocclusion had smaller ratios than those in Class I or Class III. The ratios were also linked to overjet, overbite and the space available in each arch (Vorloeper et al., 2024).
A Malaysian study compared 150 pre-treatment casts from Malay, Chinese and Indian patients. Bolton's standards fitted the Chinese and Indian groups but not the Malay group, where upper tooth excess was more common, and the authors recommended a separate standard for that population (Abd Rahman et al., 2023).
These findings do not give you a Pakistani norm. They do show that a ratio slightly outside Bolton's range is not automatically a problem. Interpret the number alongside the occlusion, the overjet and the patient's tooth shapes, not in isolation.
Measuring tooth widths on digital records
Most aligner workflows start from an intraoral scan, and most planning software reports Bolton ratios automatically once the teeth are segmented. That is convenient, but the result depends on how the software decided where each tooth begins and ends.
What the studies report on software accuracy
A study scanned typodonts and sent them for planning in one commercial aligner system, then compared the software's tooth widths with optical profilometry and digital calipers. The software measured teeth systematically smaller, by about a third of a millimetre on average. In a second part of the study using 30 patient records, widths were reproducible between scans, but Bolton ratios were only moderately reliable and had wide confidence intervals. The authors cautioned against relying on the software's Bolton figures alone and suggested that assumptions about tooth shape at the contact points could explain the error (Shailendran et al., 2022).
A later study compared three programs with caliper measurements on 55 pairs of printed models. All three were reliable for repeated measurements. For the anterior ratio, two of the programs agreed well with calipers, while the third did not. For the overall ratio, every program differed from calipers to some degree, although for one of them the authors judged the difference too small to matter clinically (Teixeira Santana et al., 2025).
What this means in practice
- Treat the software's Bolton values as a screening tool, not the final word.
- Look at the segmentation first. If contacts are tight, crowded or restored, check that each tooth outline is sensible before trusting any width.
- When a ratio is borderline and the decision depends on it, measure the key teeth yourself on the digital model or a printed model.
- Use the same software and method for each patient so that changes over time are comparable.
- Record which teeth carry the excess. An unusually small upper lateral incisor is managed very differently from generally large lower incisors.
Good records make this easier. Our photo and scan checklist covers the scan quality you need.
Managing a discrepancy in an aligner plan
Once you know where the mismatch lies and how large it is, the options are the same as in any orthodontic case. The difference is that you build your choice into the setup from the start.
- Reduce the larger teeth. Interproximal reduction in the arch with excess tooth material is the most common solution. Plan how much at each contact and when it will be done. Our article on IPR in clear aligner therapy covers safe limits and staging.
- Add to the smaller teeth. Small or peg-shaped upper laterals can be built up with composite or restored later. The setup then needs to leave the right amount of space, and the patient needs to know a restorative step is part of the plan.
- Adjust tooth position. Small mismatches can sometimes be absorbed by changing incisor inclination, overjet or the final molar relationship. Check that the compromise is acceptable for function and appearance.
- Accept a minor residual. Not every discrepancy needs full correction. A small one may be best left alone and explained to the patient, rather than chased with extra stripping.
Whatever you choose, make sure the setup actually reflects it. Compare the planned IPR, space and final overjet with your Bolton findings. If the software has added stripping you did not ask for, or left spaces you did not expect, raise it before approval.
Fitting the analysis into your workflow
- Review the scan and segmentation before reading any measurements.
- Note the anterior and overall ratios and where the excess lies, in millimetres.
- Decide on a management plan and write it in your prescription.
- Check the setup against that plan before you approve it.
- Recheck at refinement if spaces open or the overjet does not close as expected; our guide on finishing and detailing covers these late adjustments.
Training and mentorship
Tooth size analysis is quick to learn but takes practice to apply with judgement, especially when software and hand measurements disagree. FOAP can arrange training and mentorship on request. Fill in the FOAP form and our team will contact you with the next steps.
References
- Vorloeper J, Coenen FA, Lang NA, Niederau C, Knaup I, Craveiro RB, Wolf M. Digital analyses of Bolton tooth size ratios and their association to gender, angle class, and other occlusal traits: a study using a partially automated digital 3D model analysis. European Journal of Orthodontics. 2024. doi:10.1093/ejo/cjae046
- Abd Rahman ANA, Othman SA, Marya A. Measuring tooth size discrepancies using Bolton analysis: a comparative cross-sectional study among major ethnicity in Malaysia. BMC Oral Health. 2023. doi:10.1186/s12903-023-03185-7
- Shailendran A, Weir T, Freer E, Kerr B. Accuracy and reliability of tooth widths and Bolton ratios measured by ClinCheck Pro. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics. 2022. doi:10.1016/j.ajodo.2020.06.048
- Teixeira Santana T, Copello F, Marañón-Vásquez GA, Issamu Nojima L, Franzotti Sant'Anna E. Diagnostic performance of ClinCheck, Dolphin Imaging, and 3D Slicer software for Bolton discrepancy analysis. The Angle Orthodontist. 2025. doi:10.2319/022724-156.1
This article is for dental professionals and is not a substitute for clinical judgment or formal training.